AI in recruitment: are the rewards worth the risks?

AI is now being used to automate recruitment more than ever before. AI tools can scan CVs, analyse video interviews, and compare them with successful past applications to spot personality traits that fit the role, allegedly eliminating human bias.

A recent survey by Ceridian showed that 42% of executives worldwide are already using AI in recruitment, and a further 46% plan to do so. That’s basically everyone.

However, AI recruitment tools are not hypercompetent robot HR managers who can understand abstract hiring criteria the way humans can. All they know how to do is find patterns, making statistical links between features of past CVs and interviews and desired personality traits, then looking for them in new applicants.

This may not be as helpful for recruiters as it seems. The link between behavioural cues and personality is still debated by psychiatrists. The software also raises ethical concerns about privacy and consent. What’s more, it may actually perpetuate bias; if the successful past applicants are mostly white men, and you tell an AI to find people with similar behavioural cues, there are no prizes for guessing what you’ll get.

In 2019, Amazon stopped using an AI CV-scanner for exactly that reason: trained on applications that were mostly from men, the AI had become sexist. It downgraded CVs that mentioned “women’s” activities and favoured words more commonly used by men, like “captured” and “executed”. Meanwhile, a German study found that AI video analysis could be picking people based on “personality traits” like their video background, their hairstyle, and whether they wore glasses.

It’s not yet clear whether AIs can be taught to overcome this kind of bias. Training them to disregard appearance and intonation would defeat the purpose. In fact, since the AI runs on the kind of superficial differences that lead to bias, it could be more useful as a way to spot biases to avoid.

Privacy concerns also raise thorny problems; not all candidates want their personality analysed by a computer, but if they’re given the choice to opt out or select which results get shared with the employer, this could reintroduce bias: candidates might only choose to share flattering results, or interviewers could be less willing to hire those who withheld results.

Ethical AI recruitment demands highly controlled use by specialists who understand the tools. At this point, it’s worth asking whether the time and effort saved are worth the time and effort it will take to make AI recruitment truly ethical. AI analysis of hiring practices, rather than the people being hired, might be a better route to eliminate bias.

Recent Posts

Press A to Apply: Crafting Irresistible Job Offers in Gaming March 7, 2024

In the competitive gaming industry, attracting top talent can be as challenging as conquering a final-level boss. The demand for skilled professionals in game development, design, marketing, and other specialised fields has never been higher. To stand out in this crowded landscape, employers need to go beyond the ordinary and create irresistible job offers that not only entice candidates but also make them eager to press the metaphorical 'A' button and join your team.

Breaking Barriers: Diversity and Inclusion in Tech Recruitment February 28, 2024

In the fast-paced world of technology, diversity and inclusion have become imperative for fostering innovation, creativity, and sustainable growth. Breaking barriers in tech recruitment is not just a moral imperative but a strategic necessity for companies looking to thrive in the digital age. In this article, we explore the importance of diversity in the tech industry, ways companies can enhance the recruitment process to achieve greater inclusivity, and the role of recruitment agencies in building diverse tech teams.

Crafting the Future: Trends in Tech Engineering February 21, 2024

In the ever-evolving landscape of technology, staying ahead of the curve is not just a choice; it's a necessity. One of the trends that has been gaining significant traction is DevOps, a set of practices that combines software development and IT operations. The importance and business value of DevOps in today's tech-driven world cannot be overstated, and its role is only set to grow in the future.